Thanks for the responses. I did some more poking. I can confirm the car was COMPLETELY disassembled (and cut apart in some cases) and welded/painted/re-assembled. The paint is real purdy...on all the bolt holes and I'm betting that is causing me continuity issues :-(. The block is not yet in the car, so I have the negative cable temporarily grounded to the rad support. I do have a good ground throughout the engine bay and at a bolt coming through the firewall (ground for my epas system). In all cases, those points show as about 3 ohms to the negative post. Under the dash, however, is a different story For example, I thought the steering column support shown in the picture above would have decent continuity given that it's bolted in. If I test the continuity on a bare spot on this bracket, it isn't open but is 85-95 ohms to the negative post. Maybe that's good enough? That measurement seems to be consistent across other portions of the dash, when I get my probe onto bare metal. The interesting (or maybe not) part is that I function tested the instrument cluster, clock, all lights, turn signals etc and all tested fine before I tore it back apart to add the Vintage Air.
The instrument/clock panels and stereo is not in yet though I'm still not very motivated to pull the dash frame back out again to get metal-metal connections at the connection point, assuming that's the problem. I think my options are:
Leave it, assuming 85-95 ohms is just fine.
Pull the kick panels out and get the hinge pillar connection points and the dash support brackets into clean metal.
Run a good ground strap from the frame to the dash.
Right now I was leaning to #3. I'm not sure if #1 is sufficient since I don't want to have grounding problems down the road. I don't recall a dash ground in the underdash harness as discussed above but maybe I missed something putting in the new harness. Any thoughts on the options above?