So here’s the gunk I pulled out of the radiator... new radiator, hoses, thermostat, etc. this COULD be oil residue, but it doesn’t smell or feel like oil. When I changed the oil today, it looked like engine oil. No cloudiness in it. I changed it hot so it was thin, but that’s it. I did have a nice film of milky tan scum on the inside of the valve covers, in the PCV Valve, in the breather, and in the dipstick tube (but not on the dipstick when checking the oil. I originally attributed that to condensation as it’s cold and wet in dads garage for some reason.
Im not taking any chances... I ordered a gasket set. I’ll drop the pan as well and check that all the rods are still in place